Active Paths and Desire Lines
Friday July 17th 2009, 3:04 pm
Filed under: Bike, Design Thoughts, Infrastructure, Pedestrian, Planning, Transportation, Urbanism, Visualization

MFO Park

A “desire line” is the preferred path which one takes to get from one place to another, often referring to the worn path through grass, shrubs or any other location which was not designed or designated for pedestrian traffic. Chances are there is a sidewalk nearby but has been considered the less direct route and therefore is the least perferred option. I’ve been thinking a lot lately about what the desire lines and active patterns might look on a city-wide scale.

While visiting MFO Park near Zürich, Switzerland there was a very interesting phenomenon, a desire line that quite literally glowed. Even though the park acts similar to a plaza in that there are no paths, the whole site is meant for walking, there was a very distinct path that many people took on a continual basis. This connection is between the public transit and a residential portion of the neighborhood which the park essentially was placed right in the middle of. So the people just cut through the park and slip past wall-like clipped hedges that border the edge of the site.

MFO Park
images via Lisa Town

The way people navigate through space is such a huge piece of the design puzzle, it shapes cities and forms experiences. I often thought it would be really interesting to be able to track people in a more visual way in how they go about their day. I wonder what kind of patterns would form as their lines crossed large spaces, cut corners and brought to light the eaiest way in the pedestrians mind to get from point A to point B. Especially now that there is a greater shift from the vehicular and more focus on those on foot or wheels. How do these people move through the urban fabric in a vehicular world? What could their paths tell us about how a city’s infrastructure could potentially be restructured to better fit the needs of the people now and in the future?

I wrote recently in reference to an article on Copenhagenize about the bike counter. This is a really interesting device but while it may explain the chapter about how many people use a specific path and the patterns of time and day usage, such a device wouldn’t explain the whole story of perhaps what other paths people would like to use. It would be really interesting if there was a way to be able to track people ithat was effortless and allowed them to go about their typical day while still furthering the experiment. How cool would it be to deploy such an experiment and, after say a week, have the city turned into a life size urban traffic diagram?

Urban bike paths
image via contrail

Pepin Gelardi has thought of this as well and came up with something called Contrail as part of Design21’s Power To The Pedal” design competition. From Contrail’s website: “Contrail is a tool for developing bicycle communities. As you ride, contrail leaves a faint chalk line behind your bike. The goal is to encourage a new cycle of biking participation by allowing the biking community to leave a unique mark on the road and to reclaim this crucial shared space.”

Contrail points out an interesting note in that by actively placing lines where cyclists go, cars become aware of the use and the hope is that they would then become more aware and cautious of the cyclists. In addition, this could spur on more cyclists to take to the road and follow the masses with the feeling of safety in numbers.

Contrail detail
image via contrail

One interesting thought might be to tap into the power of gps devices and conduct an experiment that tracks people with these devices for a period of time, analyzing the patterns that emerge from the data. It would be really interesting to track not only bikes but pedestrians as well to get a sense of how the entire city operates and even more important, how it could potentially operate even better.


2 Comments so far
Leave a comment

not a designer but i love these ideas. regarding GPS for bikes or pedestrians, it seems that an easy way to track paths would be with an app for iphones, or other similar wireless devices. users could input their mode of transportation and participate just by living.

conversely, as an observer rather than a participant, i think time lapse photography would be great; it might not be as effective for defining paths as it would be defining negative spaces that are avoided, but that might be valuable information too.

i want a contrail for my bike.

Comment by keith 07.17.09 @ 11:02 pm

Exactly! The cell phone app was exactly what I was thinking. It would be cool if then the data could be fed live to a website that could visualize the data for people to look at and get a real sense of being part of something bigger than just themselves.

Perhaps cameras could be strategically places in areas where there are such urban voids to see how people react to them and what kind of activity goes on in the area.

Comment by Lisa Town 07.18.09 @ 9:02 am



Leave a comment
Line and paragraph breaks automatic, e-mail address never displayed, HTML allowed: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

(required)

(required)